The So-called Utopia of Centre Beaubourg, (An interpretation) – Luca Frei

An epicenter of polemics since its birth, the Centre Pompidou, aka Beaubourg, (after the working-class neighborhood that once occupied that site), is one of the few avant-garde contemporary institutions that most attracted the critics of the intellectual class of 70’s France and the world. Piano and Rogers’ design, grounded in the belief of a technology able to free man from work, was seen more as a monumentalization and taming of 1968 energies (Simon Sadler). Particularly harsh, French sociologist and philosopher Baudrillard roared:  “Model of all future forms of controlled ‘socialization': the retotalization of all the dispersed functions of the body and of social life.



Despite the controversy, or maybe probably hidden by it, a book came out almost unnoticed in those days, under the name “La soi-disante utopie du Centre Beaubourg” (“The So-called Utopia of Centre Beaubourg”), by one Gustave Affeulpin. Even before the construction of  the Beaubourg was finished and the institution only started to proclaim its political agenda of uncovering underground creativity, a second beaubourg (with lowercase “r”) was already opened underground, literally, right beneath the original one. In the form of a first person chronicle, the book tells the story of this singular space.





An epicenter of creative production against consumption, of radical making and communal life, this anti-architectural (sci-fi) dig in the ground (54 levels for 7 million cube meters of disposable volume) was a sort of mitopoietic non-place, opened to everyone, from bankers to junkies, activists and criminals, and destined to culture, namely to every culture, without any definition a priori. And, as argued by Elizabeth Schambelan, (“The view from below” Artforum, October 2007) what was really produced there was a ‘”lived critique” of something even more fundamental to Western culture than capitalism–namely, “internalized respect for Authority.”‘ (although we disagree with this assumption, as we understand the former as the condition for the latter, not as two separate circumstances).

In the underbelly of the beaubourg, private property and leadership hierarchies are abolished. Sexual behaviour and every conventional bourgeois mores like sleeping, hygiene, eating, parenting, learning, dressing, keeping track of time are overturn. Even the need for a name is considered pointless. Totally unknown people begin working together according uniquely to their spiritual needs, they share their part-time shifts outside or refuse their daily jobs altogether; notable figures like Sartre, Cardin and even Pontus Hulten (first director of the original Pompidou) happily assert they would rather spend more time there.



As more beaubourgs spring up everywhere, and the world seems to be affected by this experiment, Affeulpin can finally state : “The arts … have become the rehearsals, the practicing of the art of living, the only big Art. Culture stops being the substitute of the art of living, and History begins.” 

And yet, unfortunately, we’d add, neither this underground beaubourg, nor the author of the chronicle really existed, “Gustave Affeulpin” being the pseudonym of Swiss sociologist Albert Meister, who wrote the book in 1976 and projecting it in 1986, ten years in the future. And so, why the cover of  the English volume I bought states Luca Frei as the author? Is Albert Meister too, another fictional character?

Not really: Albert Meister, French sociologist  was not only a real, but a true mindblowing figure: as a researcher in the Ecole des Hautes Etudes de Paris, he was one of the most competent scholars of self-organized communities. He collaborated to regional decentralization programs inspired by Adriano Olivetti and even studied inflation as a transational dynamics. After living and working peripathetically in Kyoto, Belgrade, Geneva, Buenos Aires, Rosario, and Tucuman he died in Tokyo in 1982, leaving us with lots of works: books such as L’Afrique peut-elle partir?( 1966), Où va l’autogestion yougoslave? (1970), L’inflation creatrice (1975), L’autogestion en uniforme (1981) and other papers signed under pseudonyms (A. Sigolfa, C. Sniffe-Neef, Nepeutze, Gustave Joyeux).

Not that the book needed another mystery, but in fact, the 2007 edition by Luca Frei is essentially an annotated, faithful translation and useful revitalization of a document otherwise lost in the obscurity. Switzerland born, Luca Frei is a multi media performative artist, researcher, writer with a longtime interest in the everyday life, the production of space, the “archive”. Several of his works directly refer to the Pompidou. In Meister he appreciated the combination of  “a sort of absurdist humor with “very committed ideas,” so as to “challenge more dogmatic ways of writing, and of course reading.”




In a time of exacerbated Capitalism crisis, continuous uprisings and springing of communities like Occup-ies all over the world, what is the possible reading of such an old-school parable? Well, to begin with, the book has nothing to do with 70’s political vocabulary. In fact, together with bourgeois attitudes, Meister and his “beaubourgians” reject the mere ideology of “political participation”, they recognize a fair share of idiots also in the Socialist Party and state that all past revolutions have been failures. In fact, there is no Utopia, no perfect non-place, in this underground beaubourg.

Coming back to Elizabeth Schambelan’s “The view from below“, she tracks back the political discourse of Meister sociology, analyzing his theoretical 1972 ‘Vers une sociologie des associations’ (Toward a Sociology of Associations). In that book, she asserts, he seems to be “diagnosing the ills of our own present, no of his”, forecasting a technocratic society of informational elites, characterized by a widening gap between masses and power and no outright oppression, because authoritarianism does not need to manifest itself  any longer in this way. A society in which people are withdrawing into their “increasingly comfortable home[s],” with surveillance intruding in their private lives and under the “totalitarianism of mass media. “Participatory democracies are faltering as citizenries turn into vast “commercial clientele[s],” bent on the purchase of “immaterial products.” The counterculture has been neutralized, and a toxic “symbiosis” has developed between capital and the “neoartisanal sector.” 





Even though Meister asserts that perhaps the systems can be turned against itself via the subversive use of science and electronics, the only factual strategy he seems to adopt is that of the refusal of strategy:  “All we want is to refuse what will continue to keep [the world] in its grip for a long time: money and power”, says Affeulpin, “The only way to refuse the system is to negate it, to ignore it.”  We are not completely convinced by Schambelan when she says she finds a echo of autonomist Mario Tronti’s 1965 “Strategy of the refusal” in Meister’s divertissement, (read “L’operaismo italiano e il suo Sessantotto lungo vent’anni“, an Italian critical lecture of the movement in Quinterna/n+1). If a liaison dangereuse has to be provided, why not find it in the Occupy movement as a possible staging ground for revolutionary ambitions? As Twitter user “The future society” (@qqueegueg) recently wrote: “OWS  has a life of its own, it is already a foreign body in this society”.



01: The building of the beaubourg. Source

02/03/04/05/06/07 : Cover, introduction and illustrations from Luca Frei – Casco edition

08: Different editions/translations of the book

09: Illustrations from the Bürozoique French edition



Luca Frei website

Albert Meister on Italian Wikipedia

Le joyeux bordaze d’Albert Meister

Elizabeth Schambelan, (“The view from below” Artforum, October 2007)

The so-called utopia of the centre beaubourg, An interpretation Luca Frei – Casco, Office for Art, Design and Theory, Utrecht

La soi-disante utopie du centre beaubourg, Albert Meister – Bürozoique (a French modern re-edition), see latest illustrations.

Sotto il beaubourg, Albert Meister – Eleuthera (Italian edition)

Quinterna, Occupy the world together



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>